May 23, 2019
Latest News

Apple, Qualcomm end legal feud

San Diego (USA) Apr 17 (efe-epa).- Apple and Qualcomm agreed to dismiss all litigation between the two companies world-wide and forged a new license agreement, ending a long-brewing legal battle over how royalties are collected on innovations in smartphone technology, according to a report from the Dow Jones Newswires made available to EFE Wednesday.

The settlement, which came hours after opening arguments in a trial between the companies started, includes an undisclosed payment from Apple to Qualcomm. The companies also said in a joint statement that they had reached a six-year license agreement and a multiyear deal for Qualcomm to supply Apple with modem chips.

Qualcomm had claimed Apple was violating its patents by withholding royalties, while Apple argued Qualcomm had been overcharging for those patents for years, abusing its dominant position in the market. At stake was the future of Qualcomm's licensing model and billions of dollars in royalties that Apple has either paid or kept. Until the settlement was struck, Qualcomm had lost more than $25 billion in market value amid the looming threat.

The emergence of fifth-generation wireless speeds as a key component of coming devices likely drove the two companies to the table. Apple's most recent iPhones have been using modem chips from Intel, which has lagged behind Qualcomm in providing wireless features. Apple also faced falling behind rivals such as Samsung Electronics in offering speedier wireless devices.

Determining exactly who benefits by how much is difficult because the companies didn't divulge pricing or other terms of the licensing and supply deals. Qualcomm said the agreement will add about $2 in annual earnings per share as modem-chip shipments begin.

More important for Qualcomm, though, the deal also removes a significant threat to its core licensing business, which has accounted for about half of the company's profit in recent years. Apple through its contract manufacturing had been withholding about $8 billion in royalties owed to Qualcomm.

"This is an enormous win for Qualcomm because the suit and related suits were life-threatening to the company," said Roger Kay, an analyst with Endpoint Technologies Associates. "For Apple, a loss would have been financially punishing, but for Qualcomm, this would have destroyed the business. This is like a new lease on life."

Qualcomm's stock skyrocketed in afternoon trading following the announcement, jumping 23 percent to $70.45, its highest point since last October. Apple investors reacted more modestly, with its stock closing up just 0.01 percent at $199.25.

For Apple, the deal enables it to deploy Qualcomm's 5G chips in its phones - a crucial step in order for the iPhone maker to keep pace with competitors running Android software. Until this point, Apple's legal challenge had left it without access to those market-leading 5G modem chips, putting its most important product, the iPhone, a step behind Android competitors in the race to the next big advance in wireless.

Apple and Qualcomm spokeswomen declined to comment beyond the companies' joint statement.

The legal battle over how royalties are collected on smartphone-technology innovations spanned more than two years across three continents, costing the companies millions of dollars in legal fees. The discord was fueled by two chief executives - Tim Cook of Apple and Steve Mollenkopf of Qualcomm - who had a distant relationship and were entrenched in their competing positions. Both CEOs were expected to testify in the coming weeks.

As Apple escalated its fight and began withholding royalties about two years ago, Mollenkopf made a bet to accelerate more than $500 million in spending on 5G technology, people close to Qualcomm said. The move helped Qualcomm begin delivering 5G modem chips to Samsung and others early this year, increasing pressure on Apple as its Android rivals moved to the next generation of wireless, these people said.

Apple's primary modem-chip supplier, Intel, was at least a year behind Qualcomm in developing a 5G modem chip. Hours after Tuesday's settlement announcement, Intel said it would abandon efforts to develop 5G chips for smartphones, citing "no clear path to profitability."

Qualcomm's board pushed Mollenkopf for months to get on the same page as Apple and resolve the dispute, another person close to the company said.

The two companies remained in contact throughout the dispute, people close to Qualcomm said. However, serious talks didn't start until just before the trial began on Monday, according to these people and others close to the events.

Qualcomm and Apple executives then began shuttling back and forth between the companies' respective headquarters in San Diego and Cupertino (California), they said.

The parties aimed to announce a deal prior to jury selection on Monday but negotiations spilled into Tuesday morning after opening arguments began, they said.

Attorneys for Apple and Qualcomm were kept at arm's length from the negotiations so they could continue to prepare for the trial, according to attorneys working on the case.

The dramatic turn of events on Tuesday came as the two sides traded barbs during opening remarks in front of a nine-person jury at a federal court in San Diego, about 15 miles from Qualcomm's headquarters.

Prior to Qualcomm's opening arguments, Apple's lawyers sought to portray the chip company as a monopolist that had used its patent portfolio to charge onerous licensing fees of 5 percent of the sales price of iPhones sold world-wide, with the fee amounts capped at $400 a phone.

To press that case, attorney Ruffin Cordell of Fish & Richardson, which represented Apple, turned to the business of fried chicken. He compared Qualcomm's licensing practices to someone showing up at a KFC restaurant to order chicken but being told to get an "eating license" from the fast-food chain first, because the chicken includes Colonel Sanders's secret recipe. Imagine, he said, the license costs $17 and the bucket of chicken costs $17.

Qualcomm's lawyer, Evan Chesler, disputed that notion, saying that Qualcomm's business practices were more akin to a KFC that charged one price for a bucket of fried chicken and another price for a side of potatoes.

Chesler had about 15 minutes left in his closing remarks when CNBC reported that the parties had reached an agreement to settle their dispute. Chesler finished his comments and then the lawyers held a conference with the judge. A news release declaring the truce soon followed.

The agreement will "allow these tech companies to get back to business and you to return to your everyday affairs," Judge Gonzalo Curiel told the jurors.

The KFC analogy became a running joke between the parties as soon as the trial ended. Apple's head of litigation, Noreen Krall, and Chesler, Qualcomm's lead attorney, shared an elevator after the trial. "We're going to go get some Kentucky Fried Chicken," Krall said, grinning.

"And potatoes!" Chesler said.

By Tripp Mickle and Asa Fitch


News history
Massive seaweed influx in Cancun's hotel zone

Cancun, Mexico, May 22 (efe-epa).- The hotel zone along the beaches in the Mexican resort city of Cancun on Wednesday experienced a massive influx of...

Journalism in digital age must rethink how to reach its audience

By Gina Baldivieso

Geneva, May 22 (efe-epa).- Venezuela's health minister said here Wednesday that economic sanctions imposed by Washington are to blame for shortages of...

Bucking US sanctions, American Airlines expands flights to Cuba

Havana, May 22 (efe-epa).- American Airlines, the leading international carrier serving Cuba, said Wednesday that it intends to offer additional flights to...

The UK's British Steel begins insolvency proceedings

London, May 22 (efe-epa).- British Steel Ltd., the United Kingdom's second-largest steelmaker, has started insolvency proceedings after the country's High...

Rare earths emerge as China's possible trump card in trade war against US

Jesus Centeno

India's antitrust watchdog surveys e-commerce firms including Amazon, Walmart

New Delhi, May 22 (efe-epa).- India's antitrust watchdog is assessing the domestic e-commerce sector, a step that could have consequences for

Internal review reveals sexual assault cases in New Zealand parliament

Sydney, Australia, May 22 (efe-epa).- The New Zealand parliament on Wednesday admitted that at least three cases of serious sexual assault had taken place...

UN forecasts global economy to grow 2.7 pct. in 2019, 2.9 pct. in 2020

United Nations, May 21 (efe-epa).- The United Nations on Tuesday downgraded its forecast for world economic growth, announcing that it expects overall...

Plastic waste being made into ecologically friendly houses in western Mexico

By Mariana Gonzalez

Dr. AI comes to aid of China’s ailing healthcare

By Paula Escalada Medrano

Italian airline Alitalia cancels more than 280 flights due to strike

Rome, May 21 (efe-epa).- Italian airline Alitalia has canceled more than 280 flights on Tuesday amid a national 24-hour strike called by air sector unions.

US plans temporary exemptions to Huawei blacklist

By John D. McKinnon in Washington, Dan Strumpf in Hong Kong and Yoko Kubota in Beijing.

US ban on Huawei to have big impact on Europe, Americas, little on US, China

San Francisco, May 20 (efe-epa).- The decision by Alphabet - of which Google is a key unit - and other US companies to cease commercial transactions with...

Cuba and Vietnam tout solid relations during Havana meetings

Havana, May 20 (efe-epa).- The First Secretary of the Communist Party of Cuba, Raul Castro, and the Deputy Prime Minister of Vietnam met in the Cuban...

Ford eliminates 7K jobs worldwide to save $600 mn annually

Washington, May 20 (efe-epa).- The Ford Group on Monday announced the elimination in the coming months of 7,000 jobs, 10 percent of its worldwide workforce,...

Lack of bees threatens crops, experts warn

Rome, May 20 (efe-epa).- A lack of bees and other pollinators is leading to a loss in crops in certain regions of the world, beekeeping associations warned...

Huawei says it will continue providing security support for Android phones

Beijing, May 20 (efe-epa).- Huawei on Monday said it would continue giving security update to Android smartphones after Google and other major American tech...

Ryanair: This year's profit to be dented by Boeing 737 MAX grounding

By Robert Wall

Google, large US tech firms reportedly set to cut off supplies to Huawei

Washington DC, May 20 (efe-epa).- Major American tech firms, including Google, will stop selling components and software to Chinese telecommunications giant...

NIKE advertisement in Los Angeles

New York City, USA, May 19 (efe-epa).- The United States-based corporation Nike said it is adding language to new contracts for female athletes that will...

Gasoline shortage comes to haunt Caracas

Caracas, May 17 (efe-epa).- Caracas residents this Friday formed long lines to fill up their vehicles' gas tanks and even had to avoid certain service...

US reaches agreement with Mexico, Canada on lifting metals tariffs

Washington, May 17 (efe-epa).- The president of the United States confirmed Friday that his administration has reached an agreement with Mexico and Canada...

Trump postpones decision on auto tariffs for 6 months

Washington, May 17 (efe-epa).- The president of the United States on Friday postponed for six months a decision on whether to slap tariffs on imports of...

I agree Welcome to We use cookies to improve your online experience. Find out more.