June 25, 2019
Latest News
Science & Technology

Google nears win in Europe over 'right to be forgotten'

 The Google building in Zurich, Switzerland, Dec. 15, 2014. EPA-EFE FILE/ENNIO LEANZA

The Google building in Zurich, Switzerland, Dec. 15, 2014. EPA-EFE FILE/ENNIO LEANZA

Madrid, Jan 10 (EFE).- Google and other search engines shouldn't be forced to apply the European Union's "right to be forgotten" beyond the bloc's borders, an adviser to the EU's top court argued Thursday, according to a report from the Dow Jones newswires made available to EFE.

The recommendation — if followed by the EU's Luxembourg-based Court of Justice — would be a major victory for Google, a unit of Alphabet, which has for three years been fighting an order from France's privacy regulator to apply the EU principle globally.

Maciej Szpunar, an advocate general for the court, argued in Thursday's nonbinding opinion that if the EU ordered the removal of content from websites accessed outside the EU, there was a danger that other jurisdictions would end up blocking information from being accessible within the EU.

A final decision is expected in coming months from the court, which isn't obliged to follow an advocate general's opinion, but often does. No further appeal is possible within the EU.

Google didn't immediately have any comment.

Backed by an array of free-speech advocates, the tech company has argued that expanding the territorial scope of the right to be forgotten would infringe on other countries' sovereignty and encourage dictators and tyrants to assert control over content published beyond their countries' borders. The EU's executive arm also argued in September that the right shouldn't be extended overseas.

At issue in the case is the right, established by the court in 2014, for EU residents to demand that search engines remove links containing personal information — such as a home address — from searches for their own names. Under the 2014 ruling, search engines must then balance those requests against the public's right to associate the information in the link with that individual, taking into account, for instance, whether the person is a public figure.

Since that decision, Google has removed 1.1 million links from search results in the EU. But it has left those links intact for the same searches conducted outside Europe.

In 2015, France's privacy regulator, CNIL, ordered Google to expand its takedowns to any search for the given individual's name, regardless of where the searcher is located. CNIL argued that the right to be forgotten is empty if it can be dodged by spoofing one's location, for instance by connecting to a VPN. The regulator later fined Google 100,000 euros ($115,000) when it didn't comply.

Google appealed the order in French court, which referred the question to the EU's Court of Justice.

Thursday's opinion doesn't entirely back Google. Szpunar, the advocate general, recommended slightly expanding how Google applies the right to be forgotten, so that it applies uniformly across all Google websites in the EU.

Until now, the search engine has removed results from searches for an individual's name from all European versions of its website, and from non-EU Google sites when accessed from the EU country as the person who requested removal is located. Google says it does this because standards about removals vary from country to country within the EU.

But the advocate general recommended ordering Google to use the same geolocation technology to remove the results from all Google websites when accessed from any EU country.

Sam Schechner

dj/ch

News history
Chile’s Elqui Valley: An idyllic setting from which to observe solar eclipse

By Alberto Valdés Gómez

Experts: Frozen semen viable for human reproduction in space

Barcelona, Jun 24 (efe-epa).- Frozen semen is still viable in conditions of microgravity, meaning humans may be able to reproduce in space, a team of...

Ai-Da: I am the world's first robot artist

By Brenda Pérez Zapater

Apple explores moving some production out of China

By Yoko Kubota and Tripp Mickle

Vietnam calls in Russian experts to help maintain Ho Chi Minh's mummy

Ho Chi Minh (Vietnam), Jun 20 (efe-epa).- Vietnam has called on the expertise of four Russian scientists to join a team of specialists on a mission to...

Chilean scientists sound alarm as glaciers retreat

Santiago, Jun 19 (efe-epa).- Scientists in Chile warned Wednesday that the retreat of glaciers in the southern region of Patagonia as a result of climate...

Two planets discovered that could potentially support life

Madrid, Jun 18 (efe-epa).- Two exoplanets have been discovered that are warm, similar to the Earth, may have water and could be good candidates to support...

Facebook reveals Libra, ambitious foray into world of digital currency

San Francisco (USA), Jun 18 (efe-epa).- Facebook on Tuesday unveiled plans to launch a digital currency called Libra which will allow people to send money...

China biotech companies poach US talent

Hong Kong (China) Jun 17 (efe-epa).- China-based biotechnology startups looking to go global are poaching talent from the biggest American pharmaceutical...

Neurobiologist: Former athletes make best commentators

Concepcion M. Moreno

India aims to have its own space station

New Delhi, Jun 13 (efe-epa).- India announced Thursday it plans to put its own space station into orbit in the near future and has other projects in the...

India to launch its second lunar mission in July

New Delhi, Jun 12 (efe-epa).- India is set to launch its second lunar mission in mid-July to explore the south pole of the lunar surface, the country’s...

Animal fossils between 10,000-14,000 years old found in central Mexico

Puebla, Mexico, Jun 11 (efe-epa).- Fossil remains of mammoths, camels and gigantic "wolf-dogs" from 10,000 to 14,000 years ago have been found during work...

Russia, Spain make progress on development of UV telescope to Hubble

By Ignacio Ortega

What's next in payments

By Stella Yifan Xie

Halal surfing: Web browser targets 1.8 billion Muslim followers

By Noel Caballero

Cutting edge Chilean technology uses microalgae to curb air pollution

By Imane Rachidi

Washington museum to display real T-rex skeleton

Washington, Jun 4 (efe-epa).- The National Museum of Natural History in Washington DC on the weekend will open its renovated fossil and dinosaur hall with a...

The hurricane that changed US history

By Alvaro Blanco

China and its revolution of robots in production chains

By Paula Escalada Medrano

Chile creating marine algae paper to preserve fruit exports

Santiago, May 27 (efe-epa).- A "bioactive algal paper" that preserves food longer, especially fresh fruit exports, has been created in Chile using natural...

Experts stress using digital tools to make Colombian companies more dynamic

Cali, Colombia, May 23 (efe-epa).- Increasing human beings' use of digital tools is the vehicle whereby Colombia's business sector will develop, several...

Brazil reintroducing animal species into world's largest urban forest

By Carlos A. Moreno

Almaty, Kazakhstan, May 17 (efe-epa).- Springtime takes on a special meaning along the foothills of the Alatau mountains surrounding the southern Kazakh...

I agree Welcome to news4europe.eu. We use cookies to improve your online experience. Find out more.