May 26, 2018
Latest News

Gambardella: EU, China should move beyond stereotypes

 ChinaEU President Luigi Gambardella (centre-left). Photo: www.chinaeu 


ChinaEU President Luigi Gambardella (centre-left). Photo: www.chinaeu  

EU companies’ investment opportunities in China will keep on growing but the EU should understand that the super-preferential treatment it received for years is over and should move beyond stereotypes, ChinaEU President Luigi Gambardella told EPA's partner EURACTIV.COM

Luigi Gambardella is the president of ChinaEU, a business-led international association in Brussels that promotes bilateral digital cooperation.

Gambardella spoke to EURACTIV’s Editor-in-Chief, Daniela Vincenti.

The EU and China are negotiating a comprehensive investment agreement but progress has been slow. What would it take to accelerate talks?

For the time being, Chinese investments in Europe and European investment in China are still governed by bilateral investment treaties between China and nearly all member states of the EU separately. However, since the entry into force of the Lisbon Treaty, the member states are no longer competent to conclude investment agreements.

China and the EU are therefore negotiating a comprehensive agreement that will replace the 25 bilateral agreements currently in force. But a number of issues need still to be addressed.

For example, dispute resolution mechanisms became a politically sensitive issue in the EU with the conclusion of the CETA agreement between the EU and Canada, where a Belgian regional government refused to support the treaty because dispute resolution was entrusted to arbitrators.

In addition, the EU has another philosophy than the Chinese negotiators: the EU wants precise, direct implementable wording, while the Chinese side is open to leaving a margin of manoeuvre for future implementation.

The speed of the talks will depend from both sides. China and EU should both put the conclusion of the agreement high in their agenda and launch negotiations on a free trade agreement, the comprehensive agreement on investment could be concluded very rapidly. Political will is necessary. I am sure that the Chinese government and EU will put its weight behind the file.

Xi promised $124 billion (€110 billion) for the One Belt, One Road plan (OBOR), which aims to bolster China’s global leadership ambitions by expanding infrastructure between Asia, Africa, Europe and beyond. Are you confident Europe will use this opportunity to its advantage?

Infrastructure investment within the OBOR framework – for example in harbours – is beneficial for all sides.

The investments do not only serve China’s interests as world’s leading exporting country. If you look into the Chinese supported investment projects in Africa, or in some European countries like Serbia, you can see how much benefits these projects bring to these partner countries.

The new infrastructures do not only create job opportunities for local people, and local partners, but also change the business ecosystem. Trade supports the emergence of domestic activities. New skills are developed which form the basis of local startups.

Europeans are demanding that China gives EU businesses access to its market in the same way that EU markets are open to Chinese investment. What will it take for China to practice what it preaches?

We should not only look at the restrictions which still exist in China, for example, limits on foreign ownership in certain business sectors. In fact, when China sought to attract foreign investment after the start of its economic reforms 40 years ago, Beijing granted international companies in China super-preferential treatment such as exemption from certain taxes.

Today, these super-preferential policies for foreign businesses have been removed, and thus the foreign businesses have to face the same fierce competition in China’s market as the Chinese businesses do. From this perspective, it is normal that some investors are complaining.

China is still a young market economy and the Chinese government continues reducing (the) red tape that foreign investors face. I believe that EU companies’ investment opportunities in China will continue growing.

Is China’s innovation strategy a threat?

Innovation is always threatening the market power of incumbent business. The Austrian economist Joseph Schumpeter described this threat as “creative destruction”.

However, the main difference between China’s innovation strategy and the EU is that in the latter the ‘strategy’ consists mainly of speeches and dispersed subsidies, whereas in China there is a genuine policy, inherited from the practice of central planning.

China has used its successive 5-year plans to move away from being the global economy’s source of low-cost labour for manufacturing to become a leading source of everything digital. Innovation is at the core of this strategy.

This could serve as a new model for governments elsewhere. The public sector could play a role in the future as a venture capitalist, incubating and funding companies and universities directly and developing innovation labs.

But this strategy can only be successful under a strong central leadership. Not by dispersing means over regions and countries without clear focus as it happens in the EU. The EU should reform in terms of political structures and processes if it wants to remain on par with China in the innovation race.

Do you feel that the calls for reciprocity might further hamper EU-China relations?

In February 2017, France, Germany and Italy submitted a common position on screening investment from abroad to the European Commission.

One of the aims is to be able to block foreign investment on the grounds that European firms enjoy limited market access in the country of origin. Telecommunications services are an example.

While Hong Kong-based Hutchison Whampoa has become a major mobile communications operator in the EU, there are restrictions on foreign shareholding in Chinese mobile operators.

I hope that this issue of reciprocity can be transformed into an opportunity to help those in China who want to further remove these now outdated foreign ownership restrictions in China.

Today, Chinese companies are investing more outside of China than foreign companies in China. On the other hand, the debate on reciprocity should be extended to less visible restrictions, for example, based on competition rules. The EU is indeed increasingly using merger control to restrict foreign takeovers by preventing market consolidation and economic efficiencies.

Do you think China is still seen as ruthless and rapacious, a trade bully, currency manipulator, and a threat to international security through its belligerent posturing in the South China Sea?  Or are perceptions changing after the Paris Agreement and Davos when President Xi defended globalisation and championed free trade? 

I do believe that China has been insisting on mutually benefiting policies. China has been advocating multilateral cooperation, free trade and supporting globalisation. All these positive attitudes in some way are on the page of the European policies. We need to change our stereotypes when looking at China-related issues.

Useful links:

European Union relations with China (EEAS)

European Parliament Delegation for Relations with the People's Republic of China 

News history
Bullmann: Macron must decide if he is a ‘real progressive’ or not

French President Emmanuel Macron has to make his political identity clear and clarify whether he is a “real progressive” who wants to contribute to a...

Copernicus chief defends role of satellites in CAP’s ‘control’ system

The EU will launch a new satellite this week as part of the ‘Copernicus’ initiative. The earth observation programme has proved to be useful in dealing...

Faria MEP: Offshore Safety Directive is ripe for reform

The Portuguese lawmaker behind the most recent European Parliament resolution on the safety of offshore drilling explained to EPA 's partner EURACTIV...

UN Arctic chief: ‘Climate change isn’t linear – it’s accelerating’

Climate change is most evident in the Polar Regions and its impact will serve as a litmus test for what happens to the rest of the planet, the UN’s chief...

Nathalie Loiseau: Proactive policies needed to promote women’s talents

France’s European affairs minister, Nathalie Loiseau, talks about women and their place in Europe in an interview with EPA' s partner

Ansip: Europe must switch immediately to 5G

Europe must switch “immediately” to fast 5G mobile networks, EU Commissioner Andrus Ansip told EPA 's partner EURACTIV in an interview.

Minister: Malaysia will retaliate against EU goods in case of palm oil ban

The European Parliament’s decision to ban palm oil, Malaysia’s biggest export item, is “drastic and discriminatory” and Kuala Lumpur is ready to retaliate...

IOM chief: There is no migration crisis but a political emergency

EU leaders need to find the courage of unity to manage migration, which has the potential to help the EU economy grow more than expected. But the window of...

Alain Lamassoure: Transnational lists – a crazy idea

The European conservatives are opposed to the project of transnational lists for the European elections, but risk losing during the vote on the matter on 6...

Moscovici: ‘The credibility of the EU tax haven black list is at stake’

The EU Commissioner for Economic Affairs Pierre Moscovici is determined to table a digital tax proposal at EU level, despite warnings from the OECD. In an...

WEF co-chair: Greed is still the economic engine

In an increasingly fractured world, change will not happen if the current model of corporate greed continues to dominate the future, 2018 World Economic...

Karmenu Vella: ‘Well-designed’ plastics tax could help hit environment targets

As the European Commission sketches out its vision for the future of plastic production and pollution in its new strategy, the EU executive’s environment...

British Council boss: Brexit won’t change the way we help the world

The British Council will continue to do the work it has always done, despite Brexit, and its priorities in areas like Eastern Europe, sub-Saharan Africa and...

Expert: The EU political agenda must be set by ordinary citizens

Arguing for an alternative vision of European cooperation, political scientist Richard Youngs told EPA 's partner EURACTIV that an EU rethink must...

Hübner: The European Union is more transparent than national governments

Compared to the national governments of the member states, the European Union is ahead of the curve when it comes to transparency, former Regional Policy...

Dzurinda: EU must seek solution for migration outside its borders

The solution to the migration crisis is beyond the European Union borders and the EU must be prepared to talk to all relevant players in troubled countries...

Stockholm mayor: Cohesion policy is strongest form of EU solidarity

Stockholm produces more billion dollar companies than any other place outside Silicon Valley and the European Commission recently proclaimed it Europe’s...

UN Environment chief: We shouldn’t wait for the oceans to turn into a plastic swamp

At the latest United Nations environment summit, pollution topped the agenda. The man leading the UN’s quest to clean up the planet hopes this meeting will...

ECRE head: Asylum management needs compliance, not new laws

Some European countries are trying to enact restrictive policies and create a hostile atmosphere to discourage migrants and asylum seekers, blatantly...

S&D chief: ‘Employment for young Africans is a huge challenge’

On the eve of the EU-Africa Summit, Gianni Pittella says that European short-termism in migration policy will not address its root causes, and looks at...

UN chief: Migration ‘highly desirable’ if managed humanely and responsibly

For the first time, the Paris Agreement acknowledged climate change causes migration. At COP23 in Bonn, the big question is how to address it, William Lacy...

Swoboda: ‘Borissov? We have had many strange guys leading governments’

The former long-serving leader of the S&D group in the European Parliament Hannes Swoboda provided EPA 's partner EURACTIV insight ahead of the...

Tomáš Zdechovský: The EU begins in the stomach of a Czech citizen

The Czechs do not know anything about the EU’s global strategies or the interconnection of energy networks. But they know very well that they can buy...

S&D chief works for a progressive alliance away from ‘Orbánising’ EPP

I agree Welcome to We use cookies to improve your online experience. Find out more.