February 23, 2018
Latest News

EU privacy watchdog: Privacy shield should be temporary

 European Data Protection Supervisor Giovanni Buttarelli. (File photo: European Union)

European Data Protection Supervisor Giovanni Buttarelli. (File photo: European Union)

European privacy watchdogs have received “a few” complaints about the privacy shield data transfer agreement with the United States since it was brokered one year ago, the EU’s top privacy advocate said in an interview, EPA's partner EURACTIV.com reports.

A group of data protection authorities from EU member states will meet later this month (August 2017) to prepare for a first review of the agreement in Washington, in what will be a make-or-break check on whether President Donald Trump’s administration will stick to the agreement.

A handful of the watchdogs will fly to Washington for the two-day review starting on 18 September, along with a number of experts from the European Commission.

European Data Protection Supervisor Giovanni Buttarelli will not be part of the delegation, but will send another privacy specialist from his office.

Since the Commission sealed the privacy shield agreement in summer 2016 with officials from former President Barack Obama’s administration, almost 3,000 companies have signed up to “self-certify” that they comply with the programme’s safeguards – allowing them to transfer consumers’ personal data from the EU to the US.

The threat to the agreement is real

The arrangement is a tailor-made fix to keep up data flows to the US, even though American data protection rules don’t meet the EU’s privacy standards.

Privacy campaigners already filed two complaints against privacy shield at the European Court of Justice last year. The threat to the agreement is real. In 2015, the court ruled its predecessor, the EU-US safe harbour agreement, illegal. Hearings on the two pending cases have not started yet.

Buttarelli claims that the EU data protection supervisor has “always” predicted the court’s rulings on privacy cases. The office was set up in 2004 and he was made its chief in 2014.

“We can say, ‘We told you so,’” Buttarelli said.

He declined to say whether the court will knock down privacy shield, but insisted that regardless of what the EU delegation decides next month—it could suspend the deal if EU officials determine that the US is not following the rules—the agreement should only be temporary.

“In my view it’s an interim instrument for the short term. Something more robust needs to be conceived,” Buttarelli said.

“We should work in two tracks, the short period provided we satisfy the conditions. And the long one,” he added.

A strict new data protection law is set to go into effect in the EU next year, which Buttarelli says will require even tougher standards for digital trade with countries outside the bloc. That could mean that the EU must require those countries to have clearer cut data protection laws before signing any deal allowing its citizens’ data to be moved abroad, he said.

Problems to be addressed "immediately"

One hard-fought guarantee in privacy shield is a promise that US intelligence agencies will not spy on European data in “bulk” unless that is required for specific security purposes. But that safeguard is not written into US law.

Buttarelli called it “surprising” that nearly seven months after taking office, the Trump administration has still not appointed a permanent “ombudsperson” to oversee citizens’ complaints about the privacy shield, or appointed new members to the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board, a government body that monitors whether security measures restrict privacy.

Claude Moraes, a British Socialist MEP who visited Washington in June with a European Parliament delegation, said after he returned from the trip that there are still a number of problems in the deal that should be addressed “immediately”.

Earlier this year, EU Justice Commissioner Věra Jourová still showed patience with the Trump administration’s slow start to administering the agreement. While the administration hasn’t appointed an ombudsperson in the State Department to oversee the deal, there are still thousands of unfilled jobs in the State Department, Jourová assured MEPs in April.

For some in the EU delegation, patience may be running thin.

“I understand that in the US they have many other problems in this new administration, so privacy and data protection are not necessarily a priority. But if we look at the strategic dimension and what it means internationally speaking, they should realise that it should now be a priority,” Buttarelli said.

Complex negotiations over privacy shield

“It’s surprising that the biggest country in the world in terms of IT, in terms of democracy, still builds on an approach which is now objectively speaking not fit for the big data world,” he added, referring to the lack of broad data protection laws applying to different business sectors in the US.

US government surveillance was one of the thorniest issues that dragged out negotiations over privacy shield, when EU officials in charge of sealing the agreement struggled to secure guarantees from the Obama administration last year.

Buttarelli said the complicated negotiations over privacy shield could become a cautionary tale. He warned that the United Kingdom could face similar negotiations if it leaves the EU internal market after Brexit, which is expected in 2019.

“The worst scenario is that they’ll just be a member of the EFTA area [and leave the single market], in which case the whole system will be scrutinised, including intelligence, like we did for the US. Here is where we may have some interesting developments,” he said.

“That means complexity,” he added.

Useful links:

European Data Protection Supervisor

News history
Minister: Malaysia will retaliate against EU goods in case of palm oil ban

The European Parliament’s decision to ban palm oil, Malaysia’s biggest export item, is “drastic and discriminatory” and Kuala Lumpur is ready to retaliate...

IOM chief: There is no migration crisis but a political emergency

EU leaders need to find the courage of unity to manage migration, which has the potential to help the EU economy grow more than expected. But the window of...

Alain Lamassoure: Transnational lists – a crazy idea

The European conservatives are opposed to the project of transnational lists for the European elections, but risk losing during the vote on the matter on 6...

Moscovici: ‘The credibility of the EU tax haven black list is at stake’

The EU Commissioner for Economic Affairs Pierre Moscovici is determined to table a digital tax proposal at EU level, despite warnings from the OECD. In an...

WEF co-chair: Greed is still the economic engine

In an increasingly fractured world, change will not happen if the current model of corporate greed continues to dominate the future, 2018 World Economic...

Karmenu Vella: ‘Well-designed’ plastics tax could help hit environment targets

As the European Commission sketches out its vision for the future of plastic production and pollution in its new strategy, the EU executive’s environment...

British Council boss: Brexit won’t change the way we help the world

The British Council will continue to do the work it has always done, despite Brexit, and its priorities in areas like Eastern Europe, sub-Saharan Africa and...

Expert: The EU political agenda must be set by ordinary citizens

Arguing for an alternative vision of European cooperation, political scientist Richard Youngs told EPA 's partner EURACTIV that an EU rethink must...

Hübner: The European Union is more transparent than national governments

Compared to the national governments of the member states, the European Union is ahead of the curve when it comes to transparency, former Regional Policy...

Dzurinda: EU must seek solution for migration outside its borders

The solution to the migration crisis is beyond the European Union borders and the EU must be prepared to talk to all relevant players in troubled countries...

Stockholm mayor: Cohesion policy is strongest form of EU solidarity

Stockholm produces more billion dollar companies than any other place outside Silicon Valley and the European Commission recently proclaimed it Europe’s...

UN Environment chief: We shouldn’t wait for the oceans to turn into a plastic swamp

At the latest United Nations environment summit, pollution topped the agenda. The man leading the UN’s quest to clean up the planet hopes this meeting will...

ECRE head: Asylum management needs compliance, not new laws

Some European countries are trying to enact restrictive policies and create a hostile atmosphere to discourage migrants and asylum seekers, blatantly...

S&D chief: ‘Employment for young Africans is a huge challenge’

On the eve of the EU-Africa Summit, Gianni Pittella says that European short-termism in migration policy will not address its root causes, and looks at...

UN chief: Migration ‘highly desirable’ if managed humanely and responsibly

For the first time, the Paris Agreement acknowledged climate change causes migration. At COP23 in Bonn, the big question is how to address it, William Lacy...

Swoboda: ‘Borissov? We have had many strange guys leading governments’

The former long-serving leader of the S&D group in the European Parliament Hannes Swoboda provided EPA 's partner EURACTIV insight ahead of the...

Tomáš Zdechovský: The EU begins in the stomach of a Czech citizen

The Czechs do not know anything about the EU’s global strategies or the interconnection of energy networks. But they know very well that they can buy...

S&D chief works for a progressive alliance away from ‘Orbánising’ EPP

Navracsics: Education policy is tomorrow’s economic policy

Europe’s future schools need to be more skills-oriented. Faced with falling education expenditure, member states need to keep focused on their education...

Airbus exec.: EU ‘bonus’ for aviation biofuels may be too little

The European Commission’s proposal to incentivise the production of biofuels for aircraft with a 20% “multiplier” goes in the right direction, says Thierry...

City leader: Europe must simplify rules to help cities become more resilient

Europe is moving in the right direction in helping its cities become more resilient and sustainable, but the EU must streamline its myriad regulations and...

European Parliament VP: ‘We must use the window of opportunity’ to deepen EU integration

Current conditions are ideal to push the EU towards becoming a European federal state, according to one of the vice-presidents of the European Parliament,...

Jourova: EU rules on company seat transfers means savings for business

European firms could save millions in start-up and merger costs if they could use EU rules on cross-border transfer of registered office, says Věra...

EU digital official: Cyber threats know no borders

Linda Cogruedo Steneberg, Director at the the European Commission’s DG Connect , revealed how the EU executive is trying to extend broadband coverage and...

I agree Welcome to news4europe.eu. We use cookies to improve your online experience. Find out more.