December 15, 2018
Latest News

Airbus exec.: EU ‘bonus’ for aviation biofuels may be too little

 Airbus model A380. (Photo: EFE/Maurizio Gambarini)

Airbus model A380. (Photo: EFE/Maurizio Gambarini)

The European Commission’s proposal to incentivise the production of biofuels for aircraft with a 20% “multiplier” goes in the right direction, says Thierry Nowaczyk from Airbus. The question is whether this is enough to fill the price gap with fossil-based kerosene, he told EPA's partner in an interview.

Thierry Nowaczyk is Director for Environmental Affairs Europe at Airbus, the aircraft maker. Nowaczyk spoke at a conference on biofuels organised by the German Renewable Energies Agency and hosted at the Representation of the Free State of Bavaria to the EU.

There are a number of options on the table to ramp up the use of biofuels in aviation. What is your opinion on those?

We have mainly two options to foster the production and use of biofuels in aviation. The first is the European Commission’s proposal to apply a ‘multiplier effect’ to the energy content of fuel supply to aviation.

How does that work?

The European Commission first sets a target which is translated into national targets. Each member state then allocates a target to fuel suppliers to produce biofuels. With this multiplier, suppliers can achieve their targets faster, so it’s a kind of bonus for them.

The Commission has proposed setting this multiplier at 1.2, meaning suppliers will have a bonus of 20% to produce aviation biofuels. The question is whether this is enough to fill the price gap we have between biofuels and fossil fuels, which is currently between 2 and 3 times the price of fossil.

There are industry studies which are confidential at the moment but, according to our estimates, we will likely need a multiplier of between 2.5 and 5 to fill this gap, depending on the feedstock used, which may be more or less expensive.

So this is a proposal which goes in the right direction but the question is whether this is enough to really help the market pick up.

In terms of decarbonisation, how would this translate in terms of CO2 savings?

If this multiplier is enough, then we will have biofuels on the market for aviation. This means we could indeed decarbonise not only new aircraft but the entire fleet in Europe, which could have a very important lever effect.

What kind of market share do you have in mind?

If we achieve the European Commission’s target, which is already very ambitious, we could reach 6.8% of biofuels for aviation by 2030. Applying a life-cycle assessment, you can consider that you can reach a 60-70% reduction of greenhouse gas emissions on those 6.8%.

So that was the Commission proposal. But the European Parliament now comes up with something different.

The lead committee in the European Parliament, ITRE, is following pretty much the Commission proposal, with some amendments on the multiplier – ranging from 1.5 to 2 But it’s possible to go higher – in some sectors like electric cars, a multiplier of 5 is being considered.

Other Parliament committees (ENVI and TRAN) propose to scrap the multiplier and replace it with a blending mandate to incorporate biofuels into jet fuel, up to a certain level. This is a straightforward solution to bring biofuels on the market for aviation.

But the only question is the price and how it is translated in the overall fuel price for aviation. As you know, fuel is the biggest operating cost of an airline, and air traffic is very sensitive to the price of fuel so this has to be monitored very carefully.

And when you ask the stakeholders – airlines, fuel suppliers and policymakers – they have no idea of how the market will behave and what will be the price of this fuel. So I think we have to be very careful with the mandate option. It is a possible solution but it has to be initiated on a very small volume at the beginning, if any.

So the preferred option of the industry is to have a multiplier that will incentivise fuel suppliers to go on this market. Because the situation today is that we have zero volume of biofuel for aviation on the market. So we have to start somewhere and see how the market behaves.

This is the direction taken by the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) – they are targeting a reasonable target of 2% biofuels for aviation by 2025, so it’s a different timeframe.

It’s extremely small. Assuming some of these things go through, what kind of market share do you have in mind for 2030, which is the current discussion at EU level?

It is extremely small indeed, I acknowledge, because we are creating a new market from scratch. So we need to be very careful. But there are steeper ambitions later on, around 2035, where some are talking about 10%, 15% or even 30% biofuels depending on the regions of the world.

And this is where ICAO is going: start small, test the market, sort out the sustainability issues, sort out the price and volumes, and go for steeper ambition afterwards.

The scale of the objective is to have about 30% of biofuels for aviation by end-30s or mid-40s.

Is that enough to meet your decarbonisation objectives? The airline industry is aiming for carbon neutral growth by 2020…

It’s a combination of measures. Biofuels are complementary to CORSIA, the global offsetting scheme adopted at ICAO that will kick off in 2020. In parallel, we have our own system in Europe, the aviation ETS, and we have to see how the two work together. There is also the CO2 standard for aircraft that was adopted at ICAO, which will also kick off in 2020.

Air traffic management also plays a very important part in our industry. At the moment, we estimate that 8-10% of fuel is being wasted due to inefficient air traffic management. And by the mid-30s, we will have new technology on the market with more electric hybridisation of aircraft.

So it’s a combination of technical measures and policy instruments that will enable to achieve our industry decarbonisation objectives.

ICAO is meeting on 11-13 October to discuss its proposed vision on aviation alternative fuels. Are you satisfied with the way those talks are going?

For the first time ICAO and the vast majority of its 191 member states recognise that aviation needs sustainable alternative fuels in the short term to effectively decarbonise the sector and this is already a very positive move. There are numerous industry and state initiatives around the globe aiming at developing new technologies respecting sustainability criteria as well as enabling sensible business models. Therefore, beyond the questions of the targeted volume, ICAO role will be essential to frame those initiatives and exchange best practices around the world.

News history
Ex-chemicals agency chief: ‘Courage’ needed to rethink EU laws

Europe’s chemical management rules, REACH, are over a decade old and the man seen as the architect of the legislation still thinks it is the most modern of...

Parliament VP: We cannot ‘copy and paste’ Commission transparency rules

Talks between the European Parliament, Commission and Council about a mandatory transparency register – an attempt to regulate lobbying – have unfolded...

EU still leads the way on animal testing alternatives, industry representative says

The EU continues to lead the world in balancing ethics with science, although the gap with other regions is “significantly” narrowing, Charles Laroche ,...

ALDE: “we have to win over nationalists and populists across Europe,”

Madrid (EuroEFE).- Ahead of the European Parliament elections next year, over 1,000 liberals from all across the European Union last week gathered in Madrid...

S&D chief: ‘Political suicide’ for Europe to ignore Africa

Europe has to tackle the root causes of migration and better manage population flows by investing in people rather than walls, Udo Bullmann told EPA 's...

Weber: EPP has answers to populism and extremism

European People’s Party leader Manfred Weber, a potential candidate for the top Commission job, says his party is loyal to its Christian Democratic...

Stubb: No room for populism in EPP, European values are under threat

After serving his country as a minister and prime minister, and gaining first-hand experience in dealing with some of the EU’s biggest crises, Alexander...

Navracsics: I am ‘deeply interested’ in keeping the CEU in Hungary

Viktor Orbán’s offensive against the Central European University is at the core of the worsening relationship between Hungary and the EU institutions. But...

Hogan: EU member states will decide on agriculture innovation after 2020, not Brussels

Member states and not the European Commission will direct the precise support and funding for innovation and digitisation of farming in the post-2020...

Filip Grzegorczyk, PKEE vicepresident: "We would like to achieve some derogations to make capacity market work"

Filip Grzegorczyk, vice president of the Polish Electricity Association (PKEE) , participated recently in Madrid in a EFEfórum Energy debate about “The...

Italian region shows two sides to the immigration story

Images of distressed refugees arriving on Italian shores have become increasingly familiar in recent years. EURACTIV reports on the situation on the...

Refugees at the EU borders – status update from Romania

How prepared is the EU to receive people in need of protection? How can the integration programmes be improved? Those are two important case files for...

The EU’s refugee crisis: Effective handling or botched up policy?

Dealing with the refugee crisis has proved to be an insurmountable task for Europe, due to the apparent lack of a coherent immigration policy and political...

‘Kitchen of Conflict’: Through the stomach towards tolerance

Poland and Hungary are the only two EU countries that have not accepted any refugees under the EU relocation and resettlement programme. Politicians who...

Integration through language

Five years ago, the founders of ‘Teachers on the Road’ started visiting fifty refugee homes in the German states Rhineland-Palatine and Hesse. A lot has...

Névache and Briançon – left to deal with migrants on their own

Following the closure of other roads, migrants embark on a clandestine Italian-French crossing in the Alps by the Col de l’Echelle. Local residents, haunted...

Bullmann: Macron must decide if he is a ‘real progressive’ or not

French President Emmanuel Macron has to make his political identity clear and clarify whether he is a “real progressive” who wants to contribute to a...

Copernicus chief defends role of satellites in CAP’s ‘control’ system

The EU will launch a new satellite this week as part of the ‘Copernicus’ initiative. The earth observation programme has proved to be useful in dealing...

Faria MEP: Offshore Safety Directive is ripe for reform

The Portuguese lawmaker behind the most recent European Parliament resolution on the safety of offshore drilling explained to EPA 's partner EURACTIV...

UN Arctic chief: ‘Climate change isn’t linear – it’s accelerating’

Climate change is most evident in the Polar Regions and its impact will serve as a litmus test for what happens to the rest of the planet, the UN’s chief...

Nathalie Loiseau: Proactive policies needed to promote women’s talents

France’s European affairs minister, Nathalie Loiseau, talks about women and their place in Europe in an interview with EPA' s partner

Ansip: Europe must switch immediately to 5G

Europe must switch “immediately” to fast 5G mobile networks, EU Commissioner Andrus Ansip told EPA 's partner EURACTIV in an interview.

Minister: Malaysia will retaliate against EU goods in case of palm oil ban

The European Parliament’s decision to ban palm oil, Malaysia’s biggest export item, is “drastic and discriminatory” and Kuala Lumpur is ready to retaliate...

IOM chief: There is no migration crisis but a political emergency

EU leaders need to find the courage of unity to manage migration, which has the potential to help the EU economy grow more than expected. But the window of...

I agree Welcome to We use cookies to improve your online experience. Find out more.