March 19, 2018
Latest News

Hübner: The European Union is more transparent than national governments

 Former EU Commissioner Danuta Hübner. (File photo: EPA/EFE: Olivier Hoslet)

Former EU Commissioner Danuta Hübner. (File photo: EPA/EFE: Olivier Hoslet)

Compared to the national governments of the member states, the European Union is ahead of the curve when it comes to transparency, former Regional Policy Commissioner Danuta Hübner told EPA's partner EURACTIV in an interview. But improvements are still badly needed.

Danuta Hübner is a centre-right member of the European Parliament from Poland who chairs the constitutional affairs committee. She was the European Commissioner for Regional Policy from 2004 to 2009.

The EU has made efforts to make the lawmaking process in Brussels more transparent in recent years. How has this been going?

Transparency is not an objective in itself: you have to think as well about accessibility, openness, intelligibility and accountability. Transparency at all levels aims to help citizens to better understand how EU decision-making works, how it is influenced and where the different responsibilities lie. This is all about the trust the citizens have in governance in the EU.

For instance, in the Committee on Constitutional Affairs that I am chairing, we worked on a number of reports dealing with the institutional aspects of transparency of decision-making. We were calling on the Council to make its inner workings more transparent and streamlined to reflect more closely the openness that the European Parliament shows today, so that also our citizens are able to follow its deliberations as they do ours.

There is also an important part of transparency related to the access to the documents that reflect the inputs in the legislative process. A revision instrument that regulates this has been stalled for almost 9 years, in spite of the Parliament’s continuous commitment to enhance it.

You can think also about the transparency of how the EU is financed, which over the years has become a complex patchwork of instruments, inside and outside the EU. You can also look at the transparency of trade negotiations where the European Parliament has gained an ever increasing right to information in order to be able to scrutinise the negotiations on behalf of the EU citizens that elected us. Finally, some of these achievements are also reflected in the ongoing Brexit negotiations, which have proven to be an unprecedentedly transparent process as far as the level of disclosure is concerned.

Is the EU’s transparency register, in which lobbyists have to register, working?

We certainly made a lots of progress in making the interest representatives that surround the EU institutions more visible. It was the Parliament that first set up its Transparency Register as early as 1995, it was followed by the Commission in 2008 and they developed a joint register in 2011 on the basis of an Inter-Institutional agreement. It has grown on average by 1,000 registrants a year and today it covers over 11,000 organisations and individuals.

A number of technical improvements were made as far as its registration is concerned and incentives added for lobby organisations to register. The Parliament has been consistently calling for a mandatory registration system and it has ultimately brought an ambitious objective for its revision in the form of its negotiation mandate, responding to the Commission’s draft proposal for its modification.

How does the European Parliament compare to the other EU institutions in terms of transparency?

Going further down the road, not all institutions abide by the same standards of transparency. Parliament is a very open institution. This naturally stems from our direct connection to the EU citizens. All the committee meetings and plenary sittings are public and web-streamed, all the documents are directly available online and searchable through the register of documents.

The same goes for the positions of individual MEPs, the number of votes in the plenary are nominal, including naturally the final ones. Everybody can also check how we voted in the committee meetings. You will hardly find a Parliament with such high degree of transparency in the EU.

On the other hand, our partner in the legislative process – the Council – is often castigated for a lack of transparency in its decision-making. This is understandably inherent to its nature. We might be further away from a diplomatic bargaining style veiled by shade of secrecy. But the fact that it’s an EU institution, does not hide the fact that it brings together national diplomats and ministers, coming from the different cultures of transparency, with different mandates and accountabilities.

The biggest problem of course is at the highest level, when we speak about the newest and most prominent institution, the European Council. Lack of transparency at those levels of the decision-making has been consistently detrimental to the EU’s image – leaving the national leaders to misrepresent the constraints they faced at the EU level as well as well its collective achievements.

Finally the Commission, in which I myself worked as a Commissioner, has certainly a higher culture of transparency than a number of national governments in the EU member states. This is not a form of judgment, but transparency binds very much with the acceptance of its actions. And we as parliamentarians have also contributed to improving that, be it in the field of international negotiation or disclosure of the working documents discussed by the various committees and expert groups assisting the Commission in the production of delegated and implementing acts.

Would you say the EU institutions are more transparent or less transparent than national EU governments?

Transparency is enshrined in our Treaties, requiring that all EU institutions conduct their work as openly as possible; to ensure the accountability of the EU institutions and thus increase the possibilities for democratic control.

Those principles don’t necessarily always have the same resonance at the national level, but compared to a number of national institutions, the EU’s ones are certainly very transparent. If we take the example of transparency of lobbying, let’s not forget that the great majority of the EU member states have no statutory rules regulating lobbying and a great number of those that do have adopted them only at the beginning of the decade. So I would say here we are well ahead of the curve and intend to stay so.

Do you think lobbyists have too much influence in Brussels?

This is not necessarily true. Yes, there is certainly an impressive number of lobbyists. Brussels competes with Washington for the number of active representatives of various interests. But that also stems from the complexity of the regulation at EU level.

When we decide to regulate in a specific field, lobbyists are there to complete the picture and help us understand the impact our legislative activities will have on the ground, in often very specific fields. They are here to complete the picture we are getting from the expertise of the Commission, member states, consultative bodies and research carried out within our institutions. There is also a number of checks and balances – one of them is certainly the transparency register.

News history
Nathalie Loiseau: Proactive policies needed to promote women’s talents

France’s European affairs minister, Nathalie Loiseau, talks about women and their place in Europe in an interview with EPA' s partner

Ansip: Europe must switch immediately to 5G

Europe must switch “immediately” to fast 5G mobile networks, EU Commissioner Andrus Ansip told EPA 's partner EURACTIV in an interview.

Minister: Malaysia will retaliate against EU goods in case of palm oil ban

The European Parliament’s decision to ban palm oil, Malaysia’s biggest export item, is “drastic and discriminatory” and Kuala Lumpur is ready to retaliate...

IOM chief: There is no migration crisis but a political emergency

EU leaders need to find the courage of unity to manage migration, which has the potential to help the EU economy grow more than expected. But the window of...

Alain Lamassoure: Transnational lists – a crazy idea

The European conservatives are opposed to the project of transnational lists for the European elections, but risk losing during the vote on the matter on 6...

Moscovici: ‘The credibility of the EU tax haven black list is at stake’

The EU Commissioner for Economic Affairs Pierre Moscovici is determined to table a digital tax proposal at EU level, despite warnings from the OECD. In an...

WEF co-chair: Greed is still the economic engine

In an increasingly fractured world, change will not happen if the current model of corporate greed continues to dominate the future, 2018 World Economic...

Karmenu Vella: ‘Well-designed’ plastics tax could help hit environment targets

As the European Commission sketches out its vision for the future of plastic production and pollution in its new strategy, the EU executive’s environment...

British Council boss: Brexit won’t change the way we help the world

The British Council will continue to do the work it has always done, despite Brexit, and its priorities in areas like Eastern Europe, sub-Saharan Africa and...

Expert: The EU political agenda must be set by ordinary citizens

Arguing for an alternative vision of European cooperation, political scientist Richard Youngs told EPA 's partner EURACTIV that an EU rethink must...

Hübner: The European Union is more transparent than national governments

Compared to the national governments of the member states, the European Union is ahead of the curve when it comes to transparency, former Regional Policy...

Dzurinda: EU must seek solution for migration outside its borders

The solution to the migration crisis is beyond the European Union borders and the EU must be prepared to talk to all relevant players in troubled countries...

Stockholm mayor: Cohesion policy is strongest form of EU solidarity

Stockholm produces more billion dollar companies than any other place outside Silicon Valley and the European Commission recently proclaimed it Europe’s...

UN Environment chief: We shouldn’t wait for the oceans to turn into a plastic swamp

At the latest United Nations environment summit, pollution topped the agenda. The man leading the UN’s quest to clean up the planet hopes this meeting will...

ECRE head: Asylum management needs compliance, not new laws

Some European countries are trying to enact restrictive policies and create a hostile atmosphere to discourage migrants and asylum seekers, blatantly...

S&D chief: ‘Employment for young Africans is a huge challenge’

On the eve of the EU-Africa Summit, Gianni Pittella says that European short-termism in migration policy will not address its root causes, and looks at...

UN chief: Migration ‘highly desirable’ if managed humanely and responsibly

For the first time, the Paris Agreement acknowledged climate change causes migration. At COP23 in Bonn, the big question is how to address it, William Lacy...

Swoboda: ‘Borissov? We have had many strange guys leading governments’

The former long-serving leader of the S&D group in the European Parliament Hannes Swoboda provided EPA 's partner EURACTIV insight ahead of the...

Tomáš Zdechovský: The EU begins in the stomach of a Czech citizen

The Czechs do not know anything about the EU’s global strategies or the interconnection of energy networks. But they know very well that they can buy...

S&D chief works for a progressive alliance away from ‘Orbánising’ EPP

Navracsics: Education policy is tomorrow’s economic policy

Europe’s future schools need to be more skills-oriented. Faced with falling education expenditure, member states need to keep focused on their education...

Airbus exec.: EU ‘bonus’ for aviation biofuels may be too little

The European Commission’s proposal to incentivise the production of biofuels for aircraft with a 20% “multiplier” goes in the right direction, says Thierry...

City leader: Europe must simplify rules to help cities become more resilient

Europe is moving in the right direction in helping its cities become more resilient and sustainable, but the EU must streamline its myriad regulations and...

European Parliament VP: ‘We must use the window of opportunity’ to deepen EU integration

Current conditions are ideal to push the EU towards becoming a European federal state, according to one of the vice-presidents of the European Parliament,...

I agree Welcome to We use cookies to improve your online experience. Find out more.