September 23, 2018
Latest News
European Union

How the UK's David Cameron unwittingly greased the rails toward Brexit

London, Nov 30 (efe-epa).- To understand where the United Kingdom's relations with the European Union may be heading, it helps to understand how they got to where they are today, according to a report from Dow Jones Newswires supplied to EFE on Thursday.

Of course, entire books can and will be written about why the British never learned to love the EU and ultimately voted to leave in the referendum of 2016.

But the manner and timing of the UK's departure hinged on political decisions taken by David Cameron after he became prime minister in 2010.

And last week, Sir Ivan Rogers _ who was then at Cameron's side, first as his EU adviser and later as British ambassador to the EU _ shed important light on how Brexit unfolded.

Rogers's central insight is that the origins of Cameron's ill-fated EU policy lay in the eurozone debt crisis and, in particular, the events surrounding a fateful EU summit in Dec. 2011.

That was when Cameron famously vetoed an attempt by eurozone countries to incorporate new fiscal rules into the EU treaties, Dow Jones added in a report supplied to EFE.

He did so because they had refused to bow to British demands for changes Cameron said were needed to protect the UK financial-services industry from possible future attempts by the eurozone to use its combined voting weight to rig EU rules in its favor.

But the prime minister soon found that the eurozone had simply bypassed him, securing their reforms behind his back via an intergovernmental treaty that didn't require UK ratification.

The focus on the Dec. 2011 veto is clearly right.

As Rogers notes, Cameron drew important lessons from this experience: that the eurozone wasn't willing to engage with British concerns; that it would indeed privilege its own interests above those of the UK; that it had found a way to circumvent British objections; and that he would need to find a new way to deliver the changes he wanted.

The result was the decision, just over a year later, to pledge to renegotiate the terms of Britain's EU membership and then hold a referendum.

From the start, Cameron's priority was to use this renegotiation to safeguard the City's position within the single market but outside the currency union.

Only later was this strategy overwhelmed by the need to respond to public anxiety over migration.

But Rogers _ perhaps in deference to the sensitivities of former colleagues _ lets Cameron off too lightly, Dow Jones added in a report supplied to EFE.

The truth is that the Dec. 2011 summit was one of the worst diplomatic debacles in recent British history.

The draft protocol Cameron presented to his fellow EU leaders on the eve of the summit was, as Rogers politely puts it, "a remarkable document."

Along with three highly-technical second-order amendments to EU regulations, it contained three extraordinary demands to effectively rewrite the rules of the single market to give the UK a veto over financial-services legislation.

Far from a coherent strategy, this crude attempt at what the eurozone considered blackmail on a matter of vital interest appeared to have been cobbled together on the back of a cigarette packet and never stood the slightest chance of success.

Even though the strategy backfired, Rogers says Cameron had identified a legitimate area of national concern.

Yet British officials have never been able to point to any occasion when the eurozone has ganged up to put British interests, let alone financial stability, at risk _ or might do so in the future.

Out of more than 40 pieces of financial-services legislation agreed by the EU in the wake of the financial crisis, including the creation of a eurozone banking union, the UK objected to only two: a hedge-fund directive that British officials considered too intrusive and a cap on banker's bonuses.

And neither of those were the result of eurozone caucusing.

In fact, the UK welcomed most of this legislation because it simply transposed global rules the UK had helped draft.

Even so, some will argue that Cameron had little choice but to act as he did: He couldn't have persuaded his party to back any EU treaty amendment in 2011 without securing some major concession from the EU.

Others will argue that prime ministers always have a choice, Dow Jones added in a report supplied to EFE.

The option was open to him to explain the benefits of persisting with an arrangement that continued to serve British interests well.

But what all can surely agree on is that Cameron's policy failed spectacularly on its own terms.

Not only did he fail to carve out a special status for British financial sector, but also his approach ended up taking the UK out of the EU altogether.

He turned what was a largely theoretical problem into a very real practical problem as the City now contemplates its post-Brexit future.

Now it falls upon Theresa May to try to deliver the protections from outside the EU that Cameron failed to deliver from within.

Brexiters are urging the prime minister to threaten to withhold 40 billion euros ($47.5 billion) in divorce payments and crash out of the EU without a deal unless the EU offers the UK a free-trade agreement that will give British-based firms full access to its markets, while allowing the UK to set its own rules.

As Rogers says, this is unlikely to work.

And as many have said before, those who fail to learn the lessons of the past are doomed to repeat them.

By Simon Nixon

News history
Anti-Brexit demonstration calls on UK's Labour to back second referendum

Liverpool (United Kingdom), Sep 23 (efe-epa).- Anti-Brexit demonstrators took their message to the streets of the northern English city of Liverpool on...

UK Labour leaders would back fresh Brexit referendum if members show support

Liverpool (United Kingdom), Sep 23 (efe-epa).- The leaders of the United Kingdom's Labour Party, the country's main opposition, said on Sunday they would...

UK: those responsible for Rohingya atrocities must be brought to justice

London, Sep 21 (efe-epa).- The United Kingdom's foreign secretary pledged on Friday to use all the means at his disposal, including urging other nations to...

UK's May gives stern speech defending Brexit position, urging respect from EU

London, Sep 21 (efe-epa).- The United Kingdom's prime minister has on Friday urged the European Union to show more respect in the Brexit negotiations and...

Brexit on the agenda as EU leaders gather for informal summit in Austria

Salzburg (Austria), Sep 20 (efe-epa).- The European Union's national leaders began an informal summit in the Austrian city of Salzburg on Thursday to...

EU: UK post-Brexit economic plan will not work, would undercut single market

Salzburg (Austria), Sep 20 (efe-epa).- The United Kingdom prime minister's proposals on a post-Brexit economic framework with the European Union will not...

EU unveils strategic plan connecting European transport, trade with Asia

Brussels, Sep 19 (efe-epa).- The European Commission and the bloc's High Representative for Foreign Affairs on Wednesday unveiled the European Union's new...

EU Council chief: UK must renegotiate Irish border, economic relations plan

Salzburg (Austria), Sep 19 (efe-epa).- The president of the European Council on Wednesday heralded the United Kingdom prime minister's Brexit plan as a step...

UK PM May says her Brexit plan offers EU a good deal, discards 2nd referendum

London, Sep 19 (efe-epa).- The United Kingdom's prime minister stressed that her Brexit proposal, known as the Chequers agreement, offered both the UK and...

Catalan leader: Spain's autonomy vote offer must include independence option

Barcelona (Spain), Sep 19 (efe-epa).- The regional president of Spain's affluent Catalonia region on Wednesday said he would not accept an offer from the...

Danske Bank bonds fall as CEO quits over money-laundering scandal

Copenhagen, Sep 19 (efe-epa).- Danske Bank bond prices, which move inversely to yields, fell after its chief executive Thomas Borgen resigned on Wednesday...

EC: Luxembourg did not break EU rules, give McDonald's favored tax treatment

Brussels, Sep 19 (efe-epa).- The European Commission on Wednesday said it had found that the non-taxation of certain McDonald's profits in Luxembourg did...

Taxi drivers strike in Portugal over ride-sharing applications

Lisbon, Sep 19 (efe-epa).- Hundreds of taxi drivers went on strike in Portugal on Wednesday over a new law allowing electronic ride-sharing applications to...

Former Spanish PM Aznar denies knowing of any corruption in his party

Madrid, Sep 18 (efe-epa).- Former conservative prime minister José María Aznar denied on Tuesday knowing anything about a secret slush fund and illegal...

Spain to recognize Palestine if EU reaches no consensus

Madrid, Sep 18 (EFE-EPA).-The Spanish government looks to recognize Palestine as a state if it fails to convince the European Union to abandon the two party...

UK should end free movement of EU citizens post-Brexit, report suggests

London, Sep 18 (efe-epa).- The United Kingdom's Migration Advisory Committee on Tuesday released a report in which it advocated a post-Brexit immigration...

Austria's chancellor praises Italy's tough stance on migration

Rome, Sep 18 (efe-epa).- The Austrian chancellor praised the Italian prime minister Tuesday for his country's reduction in its migrant intake during a visit...

EU announces 2 million euros in aid to typhoon-hit Philippines

Brussels, Sep 18 (efe-epa).- The European Union announced an emergency aid package worth two million euros ($2.33 million) to help victims of typhoon...

EU probes BMW, Daimler and VW over emissions collusion enquiry

Brussels, Sep 18 (efe-epa).- The European Commission launched an investigation Tuesday to determine whether major car manufacturers BMW, Daimler and the...

ECB unveils new series of 100, 200 euro bills

Frankfurt (Germany), Sep 17 (efe-epa).- The European Central Bank on Monday revealed a new series of 100 and 200 euro bills that are set to enter into...

IMF issues stark warning that all Brexit scenarios will cost UK economy

London, Sep 17 (efe-epa).- The International Monetary Fund on Monday warned that any Brexit deal would negatively impact the United Kingdom economy as well...

Passenger's laptop explodes causing light injuries, smoke, panic in Madrid

Madrid, Sep 17 (efe-epa).- A total of 12 startled travelers were treated for smoke inhalation and anxiety attacks after a laptop computer being carried by a...

Bank of England warning sounds familiar

London, Sep 14 (efe-epa).- According to British media reports on Friday, Bank of England Governor Mark Carney told government ministers that an abrupt and...

1 month on: Genoa observes minute of silence for bridge collapse victims

Rome, Sep 14 (efe-epa).- Residents of Genoa on Friday observed a minute of silence in remembrance of the victims of a deadly bridge collapse in the northern...

I agree Welcome to news4europe.eu. We use cookies to improve your online experience. Find out more.