March 21, 2019
Latest News
European Union

Google nears win in Europe over 'right to be forgotten'

 The Google building in Zurich, Switzerland, Dec. 15, 2014. EPA-EFE FILE/ENNIO LEANZA

The Google building in Zurich, Switzerland, Dec. 15, 2014. EPA-EFE FILE/ENNIO LEANZA

Madrid, Jan 10 (EFE).- Google and other search engines shouldn't be forced to apply the European Union's "right to be forgotten" beyond the bloc's borders, an adviser to the EU's top court argued Thursday, according to a report from the Dow Jones newswires made available to EFE.

The recommendation — if followed by the EU's Luxembourg-based Court of Justice — would be a major victory for Google, a unit of Alphabet, which has for three years been fighting an order from France's privacy regulator to apply the EU principle globally.

Maciej Szpunar, an advocate general for the court, argued in Thursday's nonbinding opinion that if the EU ordered the removal of content from websites accessed outside the EU, there was a danger that other jurisdictions would end up blocking information from being accessible within the EU.

A final decision is expected in coming months from the court, which isn't obliged to follow an advocate general's opinion, but often does. No further appeal is possible within the EU.

Google didn't immediately have any comment.

Backed by an array of free-speech advocates, the tech company has argued that expanding the territorial scope of the right to be forgotten would infringe on other countries' sovereignty and encourage dictators and tyrants to assert control over content published beyond their countries' borders. The EU's executive arm also argued in September that the right shouldn't be extended overseas.

At issue in the case is the right, established by the court in 2014, for EU residents to demand that search engines remove links containing personal information — such as a home address — from searches for their own names. Under the 2014 ruling, search engines must then balance those requests against the public's right to associate the information in the link with that individual, taking into account, for instance, whether the person is a public figure.

Since that decision, Google has removed 1.1 million links from search results in the EU. But it has left those links intact for the same searches conducted outside Europe.

In 2015, France's privacy regulator, CNIL, ordered Google to expand its takedowns to any search for the given individual's name, regardless of where the searcher is located. CNIL argued that the right to be forgotten is empty if it can be dodged by spoofing one's location, for instance by connecting to a VPN. The regulator later fined Google 100,000 euros ($115,000) when it didn't comply.

Google appealed the order in French court, which referred the question to the EU's Court of Justice.

Thursday's opinion doesn't entirely back Google. Szpunar, the advocate general, recommended slightly expanding how Google applies the right to be forgotten, so that it applies uniformly across all Google websites in the EU.

Until now, the search engine has removed results from searches for an individual's name from all European versions of its website, and from non-EU Google sites when accessed from the EU country as the person who requested removal is located. Google says it does this because standards about removals vary from country to country within the EU.

But the advocate general recommended ordering Google to use the same geolocation technology to remove the results from all Google websites when accessed from any EU country.

Sam Schechner

dj/ch

News history
Spanish soccer league La Liga signs anti racism collaboration

Cairo, Mar 21 (efe-epa).- La Liga has paired up with the United Nations migration agency in Egypt Thursday to help combat racism.

Anne Imhof's "Sex" performance previews at Tate Modern in London

London, Mar 21 (efe-epa).- German artist Anne Imhof on Thursday previewed "Sex," the first chapter of a live performance art trilogy commissioned by the...

The guitolão: a rare Portuguese string instrument of which only 3 exist

By Carlos García

Bardot, denunciada por insultos racistas hacia los habitantes de La Reunión

Paris, Mar 20 (efe-epa).- Former French film star Brigitte Bardot was accused of racism Wednesday over remarks about the people of Réunion Island in a...

British Museum previews Munch's haunting "The Scream" ahead of UK show

London, March 20 (efe-eap).- The British Museum in London on Wednesday previewed an Edvard Munch lithograph print of his iconic "The Scream" series as...

Dear Donald: UK's May pens letter to EU in search of short Brexit delay

London, Mar 20 (efe-epa).- The United Kingdom's prime minister has on Wednesday written to the European Union to ask for an extension to the Brexit...

Google fined 1.5bn euro by European Commision over advertising

Brussels, Mar 20 (efe-epa).- American technology giant Google was fined 1.49 billion euro ($1.7 billion) Wednesday by the European Commission for blocking...

Rome Assembly president arrested on alleged corruption charges in Italy

Rome, March 20 (efe-epa).- The president of Rome's City Council, a member of the Five Star Movement which rules in coalition with the far-right Lega party,...

President Donald Trump embraces closer ties with Brazil

Washington, Mar 20 (efe-epa).- President Donald Trump said he intended to designate Brazil as a major non-NATO ally, a move that would deepen the US's...

French expert: Chantilly naked Mona Lisa sketch drafted in da Vinci's studio

Chantilly, France, Mar 19 (efe-epa).- Leonardo Da Vinci's left-handedness was the key to attributing a charcoal sketch known as Mona Lisa's naked sister to...

Man honing knife on Spanish metro in video that went viral was ham cutter

Madrid, Mar 19 (efe-epa).- A man seen sharpening a large knife on the Madrid metro in a video that went viral online was a professional ham cutter going to...

Dublin, Brussels await London's proposals for next moves on Brexit

Dublin, Mar 19 (efe-epa).- The government of the Republic of Ireland and the president of the European Council agreed Tuesday that the next step in the...

Pope rejects resignation of French cardinal convicted of child abuse cover up

Paris, Mar 19 (efe-epa).- A top French cardinal convicted of covering up allegations of child sex abuse by a priest said Tuesday that the Pope has rejected...

German minister says country exhausted by Brexit, urges UK clarifications

Brussels, Mar 19 (efe-epa).- Germany has been exhausted by Brexit negotiations and has urged the United Kingdom to clarify whether it wanted to delay its...

Order, order: what power does the speaker of UK parliament have?

London, Mar 19 (efe-epa).- The United Kingdom's prime minister and her cabinet were on Tuesday gathered together to study the next step in the Brexit...

Japan's Olympic chief, focus of bribery probe, to step down

Tokyo, Mar 19 (efe-epa).- The president of the Japanese Olympic Committee said he would step down, two months after French authorities said they were...

Holding back the past, Brexit threatens to open old wounds along Irish border

Derry/Londonderry (Northern Ireland), Mar 19 (efe-epa).- On maps of Ireland, a line cuts across the north of the island like a scar, dividing Northern...

Algerian turmoil threatens deals

Madrid, Mar 19 (EFE).- A contentious political transition in Algeria is creating uncertainty around a number of foreign investment deals in Africa's largest...

Dutch police arrest 2 after deadly shooting

Utrecht, Netherlands, Mar 18 (efe-epa).- The suspected shooter and a second person are in custody after three people were killed and five others wounded...

Trial of man linked to killing that sparked far-right riots in Germany begins

Berlin, Mar 18 (efe-epa).- A Syrian man went on trial Monday over an alleged knife killing that triggered racist street riots the eastern German city of...

Speaker of United Kingdom's House of Commons: no third vote on Brexit deal

London (efe-epa).- The Speaker of the United Kingdom’s House of Commons has Monday blocked a third vote on the same Brexit deal.

Deutsche Bank, Commerzbank shares rise on merger talks

Frankfurt, Mar 18 (efe-epa).- Shares in Deutsche Bank AG and Commerzbank AG rose Monday after the German banks said that they had entered formal merger...

UN: Israel's abuse of Palestinian resources is a human rights violation

Geneva, Mar 18 (efe-epa).- The United Nations denounced Israel's ongoing exploitation of Palestinian natural resources and its use of force during protests...

Report: Boeing 737 MAX jet draws US criminal probe

Washington DC, Mar 18 (efe-epa).- Federal prosecutors and Department of Transportation officials are scrutinizing the development of Boeing's 737 MAX...

I agree Welcome to news4europe.eu. We use cookies to improve your online experience. Find out more.